• Blog
  • About
  • Contact
Francene--Blog. Year 2014

The fine line between theft and emulation.

11/24/2014

8 Comments

 
Picture
A letter sent to a friend by fellow writer Neal Cassady has been found after more than half a century. It was considered one of the greatest losses in literary history. The poet friend Jack Keroac had been credited with launching the Beat genre, however, he stole the stream of consciousness style after reading the letter to write his novel On The Road. Critics say had the letter not been lost, it would have transformed Cassady into a towering literary figure.

According to California auction house Profiles in History, who are auctioning the letter, it was never lost, but rather misplaced.

Poet Allen Ginsberg had tried to get the letter published and mailed it to Golden Goose Press in San Francisco. There it remained, unopened, until the small publishing house folded. The owner planned to trash every unopened submission he still had in his files. However, the operator of a small, independent music label who shared an office with publisher took every manuscript, letter and receipt in the Golden Goose Archives home with him.

The note was an 18-page rambling stream of consciousness to his friend in 1950. Here's an excerpt of a letter that started the fuss.

I am sitting in a bar on Market St. I'm drunk, well, not quite, but I soon will be. I am here for 2 reasons; I must wait 5 hours for the bus to Denver & lastly but, most importantly, I'm here (drinking) because, of course, because of a woman & what a woman! To be chronological about it:

I was sitting on the bus when it took on more passengers at Indianapolis, Indiana – a perfectly proportioned beautiful, intellectual, passionate, personification of Venus De Milo asked me if the seat beside me was taken!!! I gulped, (I'm drunk) gargled & stammered NO! (Paradox of expression, after all, how can one stammer No!!?) She sat – I sweated – She started to speak, I knew it would be generalities, so to tempt her I remained silent.

She (her name Patricia) got on the bus at 8 PM (Dark!) I didn't speak until 10 PM – in the intervening 2 hours I not only of course, determined to make her, but, how to DO IT.

I naturally can't quote the conversation verbally, however, I shall attempt to give you the gist of it from 10 PM to 2 AM.

Without the slightest preliminaries of objective remarks (what's your name? where are you going? etc.) I plunged into a completely knowing, completely subjective, personal & so to speak "penetrating her core" way of speech; to be shorter (since I'm getting unable to write) by 2 AM I had her swearing eternal love, complete subjectivity to me & immediate satisfaction. ...

Picture
#Wikipedia# The idea for On the Road, Kerouac's second novel, was formed during the late 1940s in a series of notebooks, and then typed out on a continuous reel of paper during three weeks in April 1951. It was first published by Viking Press in 1957. After several film proposals dating from 1957, the book was finally made into a film.

He started working on the first of several versions of the novel as early as 1948, based on experiences during his first long road trip in 1947. However, he remained dissatisfied with the novel. Inspired by a thousand-word rambling letter from his friend Neal Cassady, Kerouac in 1950 outlined the "Essentials of Spontaneous Prose" and decided to tell the story of his years on the road with Cassady as if writing a letter to a friend in a form that reflected the improvisational fluidity of jazz. In a letter to a student in 1961, Kerouac wrote: "Dean and I were embarked on a journey through post-Whitman America to FIND that America and to FIND the inherent goodness in American man. It was really a story about 2 Catholic buddies roaming the country in search of God. And we found him."
 

So, Kerouac stole Cassady's writing style and made his fortune.

Nowadays, novices are advised to study the writing of great authors and try to emulate them. I guess Kerouac did nothing more than that. He did the work while using his friend's style.

Is this any different than following a great leader, or sharing inspiring quotes?

8 Comments
Sharon Martin link
11/23/2014 06:35:43 pm

Wow I bet the music label owner was really pleased to have taken that bundle home, Imagine having lost that forever !

Reply
Zoe Halliday link
11/23/2014 06:45:40 pm

Amazing to think of the may unopened treasures still out there waiting to be discovered

Reply
Alana link
11/23/2014 07:24:51 pm

I remember reading about young people studying painting hundreds of years ago, who were expected to copy and reproduce paintings by old masters until they developed enough skill to do their own work. Kudos to the man who kept the records from being destroyed. I love it when lost treasures are found.

Reply
Manu Kalia link
11/23/2014 08:22:16 pm

I consider this a treasure.

Reply
Kristen from The Road to Domestication link
11/23/2014 09:03:33 pm

How interesting! I love when "lost" things are found! Such as when several shots from Ansel Adams were found at a yard sale here in the states recently! Definitely good inspiration!

Reply
K.Lee Banks link
11/23/2014 09:28:41 pm

I agree with the others about the value of finding such a valuable treasure and contribution to literary history.

Regarding the line between theft and emulation - this is certainly a common problem in academia, where so many students "copy and paste" or routinely use other people's work with no attribution, and think nothing of it...that is, until they get caught for plagiarism!

Reply
Barbara link
11/24/2014 01:02:29 am

There is nothing new under the sun. It is good to emulate and study treasures like this. :)

Reply
elly stornebrink link
11/24/2014 11:58:23 am

Francene, you bring up some valid points. On the one hand, I think as long as one credits the author/poet/writer etc. then that is enough. On the other, I think if someone were to 'steal' my inspirational ideas and then get credit for it (and I not0, then I would be offended. So, hmmm...where lies the balance? I will have to ponder that some more I guess! ;) <3

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Francene Stanley:
    Author
    I use news items in my fantasy novels.

    Born in Australia, I moved to Britain half way through my long life. If you like my writing, why not consider purchasing one of my books on the sidebar below?
    I blogged 260 days last year. Link.

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    Archives

    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013

    Categories

    All
    Animals
    Birds
    Earth
    Environment
    Experience
    News
    Novel
    People
    Society
    Writing

    RSS Feed

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.