• Blog
  • About
  • Contact
Francene--Blog. Year 2014

The Dutch pay working alcoholics with beer.

1/6/2014

15 Comments

 
Picturewww.examiner.com
The news today reveals that a group of alcoholics who once despised their city are cleaning the streets of Amsterdam. They are paid with beer as part of an initiative to reduce crime in the parks, and are making a positive difference in a community where they were once despised.

The Rainbow Group is a carefully monitored private but primarily government-funded company, which helps people struggling to cope due to homelessness, drug abuse or alcoholism. 20 alcoholics have joined this initiative. They arrive at 09:00 and work until 15:00, scouring the streets for rubbish. Inside a communal space, the workers take extended breaks for beer, cigarettes and a hot lunch, all provided free of charge. Now, instead of being shunned by society, the alcoholics' needs appear to have been incorporated into the Dutch healthcare system.


Picturewww.nytimes.com
The founders of this project treat this addiction as an unchangeable reality to be tackled using a method guaranteed to connect with the patients.

The woman who runs who runs the Rainbow Group's litter project says the project is cost-effective. They have tried many ways of getting people off alcohol, and this one addresses the problem. The environment is better off, the alcoholics have more quality of life, and they give something back to the community, rather than citizens paying to keep them in jail.
Most Dutch people are in favor of the scheme.

Since the street-cleaning project started 12 months ago, local police have received fewer reports of stabbings and muggings in the park. Other cities in the Netherlands are considering introducing similar schemes.


Picturemoney.excite.co.uk
The Rainbow Group is hoping to attract more funding and help them to reach the unreachable. In dealing with this problematic group, the project attempts to reduce the harm caused by alcoholism in a method similar to programs given to drug addicts.

From my experience of living with a man who once bought two packets of cigarettes a day, smokers could come under this heading. For two years, my husband has used the free services of the UK's National Health Scheme to cut down on smoking. He's over 75 years and he started smoking in his teens. The health advisors accept that he will probably never be free of his cravings. But at least he can cut down on the harmful cigarette smoke associated with the nicotine. Another case of damage control.

I'm in favor of the Dutch Government's scheme to give alcoholics a sense of mattering in their society. I hold as an example the Salvation Army and their compassion to homeless people no matter what their circumstances. The way I see it, we're all working toward perfection. In life, our freedom of choice presents various temptations. Some succumb and others go on to face another challenge. We should help our fellow man along the path.

What do you think of Amsterdam's initiative?


15 Comments
Sophie Bowns link
1/5/2014 07:01:57 pm

They are paying them with beer?! That's like paying a drug addict with cocaine! What on earth are they thinking! How are these people supposed to battle their addiction if they are just being encouraged?

Reply
Francene Stanley link
1/5/2014 07:32:35 pm

The only thing they can do is give them something to do with their lives.

Reply
Lauri Rottmayer link
1/5/2014 07:26:45 pm

I had actually heard of this before and I love the idea! Of course I also think we should use people collecting welfare in America to do the same thing which I'm sure would not be a popular opinion. I feel like this turns a negative into a positive. Two thumbs up! :-)

Reply
Francene Stanley link
1/5/2014 07:34:23 pm

Great to get a positive opinion on this, Lauri. Turning negative into positive is always a winner.

Reply
Amy link
1/5/2014 09:53:20 pm

Well, Francene, my first thought is that these people at least are doing something constructive for 6 hours of the day. They aren't just sitting in the curb, say, drinking alcohol all day long. It seems like it could be a good thing, even though paying alcoholics with alcohol does give me pause . . I guess it'd be better, in my mind, if there was some sort of a drinking cessation program going on with them, too, teaching them how to replace their alcohol addiction with productive work and fulfillment, instead? Fascinating as always, Francene!

Reply
Francene Stanley link
1/5/2014 10:14:32 pm

I guess the work and fulfillment is part of the plan.

Reply
Roy A. Ackerman, PhD, EA @ Cerebrations.biz
1/5/2014 10:00:18 pm

I'm guessing Rainbow decided that if feeding addicts methadone is acceptable (on a predetermined schedule), so could providing beer to alcoholics on a predetermined schedule. Especially if the local community gets some sprucing up in the bargain.

Reply
Francene Stanley link
1/5/2014 10:16:11 pm

At least they're working, Roy. Along with socializing and contacting people who offer help.

Reply
Beth Camp link
1/5/2014 10:45:18 pm

Thank you for writing about this very humane idea for homeless alcoholics, Francene. What a fascinating idea! I can't see any city in the states adopting this one, but it makes perfect sense.

Reply
Francene Stanley link
1/6/2014 02:07:11 am

I agree. I love to think of these hopeless people having something to drive them each day.

Reply
Ilesha link
1/6/2014 12:14:08 am

What a fascinating & "out of the box" solution! And if the city is seeing benefits & crime reduction then it seems to be working. However, I would love to see some type of mental health componen Addiction is curable

Reply
Francene Stanley link
1/6/2014 02:08:44 am

I'm glad it's working and that more people are willing to try the method of helping these people.

Reply
Lynda Lippin link
1/6/2014 12:18:57 am

I find that in the US we tend to try to replace addictions with others that we find less distasteful. So we take heroin addicts and get them addicted to methadone. We take alcoholics and get them addicted to caffeine and cigarettes (ever been to an AA meeting?). We refuse to work with what is. And the system is not working. This, on the other hand, is a great idea!

Reply
Francene Stanley link
1/6/2014 02:10:31 am

Interesting thoughts on this difficult subject, Lynda. No, I haven't been to an AA meeting. What a revelation about caffeine and cigarettes.

Reply
MallSaleLover link
1/6/2014 09:26:39 am

That will be like killing their workers slowly.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Francene Stanley:
    Author
    I use news items in my fantasy novels.

    Born in Australia, I moved to Britain half way through my long life. If you like my writing, why not consider purchasing one of my books on the sidebar below?
    I blogged 260 days last year. Link.

    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture

    Archives

    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013

    Categories

    All
    Animals
    Birds
    Earth
    Environment
    Experience
    News
    Novel
    People
    Society
    Writing

    RSS Feed

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.